Last week I talked about books I liked as a child and K-12 student — and those I didn’t like but was forced to read for English class.
I forgot one of those books: the book I call my favorite book ever. Looking back I think I read this book as part of that special “advanced reading group” in junior high. I thought it was seventh grade, but it was probably ninth grade. Oh, the name of the book? A Separate Peace* by John Knowles. I don’t know why that book had such an impact on me. I remember only the main character, Phineas, and the fact it was about young men going to war. And one other thing that might be a spoiler in case you haven’t read the book. Several years ago — probably more than that — I tried to read the book again, and it was just too heavy in my later years! But at the time I read it, I went on to read other John Knowles books, including Indian Summer, which I believe was a sequel to A Separate Peace, and The French Lieutenant’s Woman.
I don’t recall ever seeing a movie of A Separate Peace, but I just looked it up and the movie does exist, so I might have seen it. I would buy it now, but I have neither a way to play DVDs or VHS tapes!
I was a double major in Print Media and English Literature, so I know I took at least eight specialized English courses. I don’t remember them all. I do remember the British poetry: Blake, Coleridge, Byron, Shelley. I didn’t like any of it. Who knows why I majored in English! Confessions of an Opium Eater gave some promise of enjoyment, but I think I was disappointed. I am sure I took a course in earlier works because I remember reading The Canterbury Tales, which weren’t so bad.
I remember a course in more modern American writers, but remember none of the books except perhaps Agee’s A Death in the Family. Maybe some of the books I remember reading at some point around that time were included in that class.
Two of my English classes were favorites. One was a Shakespeare class taught by the world famous (late)Wylie Sypher. We read a number of Shakespeare’s plays, but the only one I remember loving is Othello, which remains my favorite. The other great class was Music in Literature. It was in the music department, which consisted of three courses, all of which I took. Nothing stands out in my mind about that class — which was basically an opera class — except Tristan and Isolde, which I just loved. I remember nothing about either of those favorite works.
During my college and young adult years, I read many of the books that were trendy at the time. These were the 70s and 80s. Here are some of them:
- A couple of books that would be too heavy for me now were John Barth’s The Sotweed Factor and Gunther Grass’s The Tin Drum*. Loved them both.
- Read some Steinbeck including The Grapes of Wrath (likely for some class), Cannery Row, and Tortilla Flat. The last two were of my own choosing during my Steinbeck “thing.”
- Not so many notable African American writers then, but I read Native Son by Richard Wright and The Invisible Man by Ralph Ellison.
- And of course I read some Fitzgerald: Tender Is the Night and The Great Gatsby (possibly for a college course).
- And whatever I read by Hemingway and Faulkner I didn’t like.
- Who can forget Vonnegut, the most notable writer of my college days? I read them all.
- I had a thing about D.H. Lawrence for a while and read several. First, of course, Lady Chatterly’s Lover* and then Sons and Lovers.
- I did read the first 110 pages of War and Peace. And that was that.
- The Hobbit* and the Lord of the Rings trilogy are among my all-time favorites. I read The Hobbit to my kids when they were little. I still have those four books.
- Did the dystopian thing too, although I am not sure when: 1984, Animal Farm*, Lord of the Flies*, A Clockwork Orange. I think Animal Farm may have been part of that advanced reading group too. Animal Farm is one of my favorites.
- Read some popular sci fi, including Brave New World by Huxley, Stranger in a Strange Land by Heinlein, and Dune* by Herbert.
- Oh, and I read the junk: Valley of the Dolls and Peyton Place!
- I did not ignore the “classics,” although there are many I didn’t read. I liked Tess of the Durbervilles, Madame Bovary, and Far from the Madding Crowd* by Hardy.
- I read the creepy ones: Rosemary’s Baby, The Exorcist, and In Cold Blood.
Here are some of the other books I read and really liked. And if you are of my era, you likely did too!
- Catch 22*
- The Bell Jar by Plath
- Night* by Elie Wiesel
- Myra Breckinridge by Gore Vidal
- The Word According to Garp*
- On the Road* by Jack Kerouac – still have that one too.
- Franny and Zooey* by Salinger
- Naked Lunch by Burroughs
- The Chosen* by Chaim Potok
- Portnoy’s Complaint* and a lot of others by Philip Roth
- Tropic of Cancer by Henry Miller (no relation) because it was supposed to be, you know…..
- Dead Souls by Gogol
- Ragtime* by Doctorow
- Jonathan Livingston Seagull, inscribed to be in 1974 by my then boyfriend. I had it until recently and I had to do away with it!
- Oh, and that one about the meat factory by Upton Sinclair — or do I have two books confused???
- And Catcher in the Rye*!!
If you haven’t read some of those books, I would recommend them, especially the ones I have starred! Don’t commend me on my fabulous memory. When I started to use Goodreads, I put all the books I could remember reading in my life on the list. So I just looked at the list. However, I didn’t look at it carefully or look at how to spell the author’s names. I wanted this to be more organic: how I remembered them, or to see if I could remember them. So I apologize if I spelled any author names wrong or tweaked the titles a bit.
Happy Reading!
Bruce says
Thank you so much!
I am so pleased to have your book list. I have been reading up a storm since retiring, Steinbeck, London, Hawthorne, Kipling, and so on. I’ve read a few (maybe a dozen or so) on your list) and now will use it as a springboard for my future reads.
It is great to have your list. Such an inspiration!
By the way, the Sinclair book about meat packing in Chicago is The Jungle.
Bruce
Arlene Miller says
That’s right! The Jungle! Glad to provide some book ideas. If you read A Separate Peace, let me know what you think!
Julia says
I took a novels class my junior or senior year of undergrad (English major here too) and the professor handed out a questionnaire on the first day of class. I remember one of the questions was what book we had read recently that we hated. “The World According to Garp” was my answer. He read those questionnaires because he brought mine up the next class period. He asked who wrote that answer. I raised my hand and we had a moment. He said, “wasn’t it awful? I agree.”
Sorry to rain on your Garp memory.
Arlene Miller says
I don’t remember loving it, but I liked it enough to finish it and see the movie! Now if you had said that about A Separate Peace!!!
Julia says
I read A Separate Peace one year in school and I remember liking it but little else. Is that the one where they jump out of a tree? I’ve had The Sotweed Factor on my bookshelf (unread) for a decade. I read mostly fantasy books these days as I gravitate toward fun and magic. “Heavy” doesn’t sound like a 2021 read.
Arlene Miller says
I am with you. I don’t read anything much heavy these days except some political nonfiction. Give me light chick lit or women’s fiction. Or cozy mysteries. I don’t remember anything about A Separate Peace except Phineas and war. Yes, but was he thrown out of the tree???????
Dave LaRoche says
And you missed Moby Dick. I am surprised. But great list and many I’ve passed by in the past but will now from your list select. Thanks for that.
Arlene Miller says
You are very welcome! I read Moby Dick in high school. I hated it. Sorry.
Jo Ann Triebel says
My favorite book is To Kill a Mockingbird. Read the sequel that was found after Harper Lee passed away. Go Set a Watchman. Very interesting perspective from Scout.
Arlene Miller says
I forgot that one. I read both of them. Actually, I read To Kill a Mockingbird years after most people probably did. It was one of those famous books I have never read and knew that I should. I don’t think I liked the sequel very much.